Two Book Critics Consider The Lines Between Praise, Fairness, And Meanness

Thomas Mallon: "Today's literary reviews too often turn into participation trophies, quiet tour-guide appreciations. Few things, of course, are duller than self-indulgent put-downs; but informed and spirited dismissals are another matter, and they remain in too-short supply."
Liesl Schillinger: "There's a distinct line between eulogy and fairness, but every critic knows you make more of a splash when you wield a bludgeon than when you bestow a bouquet. Yet Trollope also recognized that brickbats too readily brandished lose their power to stun."

Article source here:Arts Journal